Food Review: Subway’s Pizza

First, Happy Link Time!

1) is the blog which features my stuff every Tuesday.  That is good enough reason to support them.  Outside of that, it’s quite simple to enter.  All you have to do is…wait, are those the bad joke sirens?  OK, moving on.

2) will be my second home from April to September, as I’m returning to the Syracuse Chiefs for some Triple-A baseball broadcasting.  In fact, that’s where I got the idea for today’s review, as part of our “Chiefs Culture Challenge” between fellow broadcaster Jason Benetti and me.  Head over there for more wittiness.


I’d estimate I’ve been to Subway at least 200 times in my life.  That’s probably selling it short, to be honest – and I’ve probably used somewhere in the neighborhood of 65 Subway gift cards.  One might characterize my love of Subway as an obsession.  One would be correct.  Hypothetically.

No es amor, though.

But never had I eaten the Subway personal pizza.  Nor had I ever considered the Subway personal pizza.  Nor had I realized every Subway had a personal pizza.  Nor had I ever uttered the words “Subway”, “personal”, and “pizza” in the same sentence.  But today, I took the plunge off the deep end – a deep end likely to be about three feet deep – and ordered a personal pizza from Subway.  Bad idea – or worst idea?  (Well, I’ve already chronicled a Pitbull song and a Snapple from the Mesozoic Era, so let’s stick with “bad idea.”)

First things first – I had to make sure my local Subway even had pizza.  On, the menu showed no sign of pizza – a real shot of confidence in the arm.  “Oh, look, I’m about to eat something that the website doesn’t even acknowledge!”  That’s an approximation of the thoughts that were inside my head earlier today.  I mean, seriously…can you imagine the Yankees just refusing to list the 25th man on their roster on  Or Barnes & Noble hiding all evidence of the Twilight series?  (You know, what that one actually makes sense.  You know what else, teenage girl readership just declined on this blog by 37%.  Which I think is the combined Rotten Tomatoes score of all the Twilight movies.)

Team Edward, if you were wondering.

Anyway, back to the pizza, before I’m decapitated by a flying Taylor Lautner cardboard cutout…I walked into Subway and, to my slight surprise, saw a sign of $5.00 personal pizza!  It existed!  I then asked the woman behind the counter, in my most awkward I-really-wish-I-wasn’t-doing-this-and-I-don’t-know-you-but-please-don’t-judge-me voice, “do you…happen to have…pizza?”  Without responding, she departed into the back, where she stayed before emerging approximately two to 17 minutes later.  During this time, I imagine she was doing one of three things:

1) Trying to conceal her hysterical laughter.

2) Going into the secret pizza room in the dungeon.

3) Crouching under a dresser drawer to dust off the most recent pizza shipment from two years ago.

I was starting to feel really bad about my choice at this point.  But thankfully, the woman emerged, pizza in hand!  Saran-wrapped and all.  (Is it a good thing when the pizza is saran-wrapped?  No?  Right.)  Then came the most hilarious moment of the entire ordeal – the clearly flummoxed woman turned the regular oven on, only to then place the pizza in the microwave oven.  This women clearly had no clue what to do with the pizza.  She was more confused than Tim Tebow at a Grateful Dead concert.  (Word.)

Out of the saran wrap and into the microwave went the pizza, as two women walked up behind me.  I had never seen these women before, I do not know who they are, and I likely will never see them again, yet I still felt downright ashamed at that moment.  I quickly attempted to rectify the situation by ordering a six-inch Chipotle Chicken and Cheese sandwich, which I also felt would be a good alternative to the likely tasteless pizza.

The pizza was in the microwave for 90 seconds, which is the exact same way that pizza is cooked at any other reputable pizza place in the world.  At this point, Domino’s was looking like a good alternative, and I wouldn’t even use Domino’s to save world hunger if given the chance.  The woman behind the counter was so flummoxed at this point, she put Chipotle sauce on my sandwich before toasting it – and then asked if I wanted more post-toast.  I felt like Will Ferrell in Wedding Crashers – I had no idea what she was doing back there.


Finally, mercifully, I put in the cash for my purchase and headed back to work to chow down on the magical, mystical, cheesy concoction.  I decided to go pizza first and sandwich second, guaranteeing I would exit the meal on top.  The pizza was similar in shape and size to a Celeste pizza for one – a homemade frozen food I happen to love – but it looked about 16 times less crispy.

And it tasted that way.  The pizza was certainly closer to the soggy kind than the crispy one – but truth be told, it wasn’t that bad.  The taste was mediocre, the crust was mediocre…the whole thing was mediocre!  An unbridled success, if you ask me, especially since I might be the third person to eat pizza since that Subway opened.  (The drunk guy from the bar at 4:00 PM that one day was the first, and the dude who’s allergic to all kinds of Subway bread but not pizza dough was the second.  We’re connected on LinkedIn.)  This was probably the most pleasant surprise I’ve had since…well, Chronicle on Monday, which was only three days ago.  (Man, that example wasn’t as fun as I thought it would be.  I should really stop taking stuff literally.)

Anyway, don’t get the Subway pizza, but at least you won’t die if you do!*

*Pending my death

Grade: C-


One final side note from yesterday’s review: my sister, who turned 17 today, came home with a stuffed red Angry Bird.  It has a “Squeeze Me!” tag.  However, when you squeeze it, it does not make any noise.  How cute!

Man, I hate that game.


11 responses to “Food Review: Subway’s Pizza

  1. “A” on this blog entry. Virtually anything that has to do with food will get a good grade from me; but when you combine Subway with stories of your social awkwardness, it puts it over the top. Shameless burns at Twilight (“teenage girl readership just declined on this blog by 37% which I think is the combined Rotten Tomatoes score of all the Twilight movies”) is just one of the many reasons why I’ll keep coming back to this blog. At least until I get bored.

  2. In response to the ending part of the blog entry (regarding the Angry Bird)… My brother got me a red stuffed angry bird for Christmas. It either makes that sound when you shoot it, a cheering sound, or a maniacal laugh. I’m sorry hers makes no sound.

  3. The first problem, the employee that was working. Subway Pizza does not go in the microwave. I know this because the subway I work next door to makes them a lot. This is how it works here. They remove the frozen disk of dough from the plastic wrap. Then they ask you if you want any topping on it. They pretty much let you put anything on it that you would put on your “samich”. Once the toppings (if any) have been disproportionately applied they should cover it with an additional layer of very cheap shredded mozzarella. Then in the junk oven it goes. After several minutes it comes out of the oven. You’ll promptly know you have made a bad ordering choice once you notice the edges of the pizza have been burnt beyond anything that remotely resembles and pizza and the center looks just as it did before it went in the oven. What you end up with a pizza with a very hard rock like outer crust (at least it’s crunchy) and sauce on the edge so hot it will not only remove several layers of skin from the roof of your mouth but the mouth of person in the next booth. We’re talking molten lava hot. But it’s OK, as you’ll soon reach the center that will usually have the texture of a bowl of corn flakes that was left sitting in milk for an hour (but hey, at least it’s not lava hot) and this will help cool the now forming gigantic blister on the roof of your mouth.

    With all of that said, I must say, This has been one of the most entertaining blog posts I have stumbled upon ever.

    • It just came to Canada recently so I ventured to try it, just a plain cheese pizza, as I just wanted to see how it would taste. I tried it 2 days ago, and the roof of my mouth is still burnt. I know exactly what you mean. LOL

  4. I would say the blog is interesting, though terribly incorrect. I would say the blame lies in the hands of the lady that was making your pizza that day. Pizza doesn’t really go in microwave, it has different oven. With your choice toppings and additional cheese, and your choice of crispiness, pizza is highly personal and great tasting. I have had it almost 10 times now. Compared to Dominos or Pizza Hut, subway pizza is heaven for me.

    Whenever I have it, I always wonder, why won’t they put it on menu on their website?

  5. I tried the Subway Veggie Pizza for the first time yesterday because they looked so good the last time I was there. It was so good with a crispy crust. It went into the same device where they toast the subs. Looked, smelled and really tasted so good.

  6. I agree with you. Dont get their pizza. My step mom brought me one from subway. At first i opened the box and was in disbelief at hoe disgusting it looked. It has no “crunchy” anywhere. Its soggy feeling and everything. Barely has sauce, its like all n the middle, and last, too much cheese. Never Again.

  7. personally i love that pizza i dont know what it is about it, i hope they dont get rid of it because I really do enjoy it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s